Skip to content

Is Google Maps Enough for Your Technicians, or Do You Need a Route Planner?

SHORT ANSWER
Google Maps is a navigation app, not a route optimizer. Its own help page says you can add up to 9 stops on desktop and gives you a drag-and-drop way to reorder them, and it does not mention automatic sequencing. For one technician with a handful of fixed-time visits it is often enough. Once you have several techs, time windows, same-day changes or more than about eight stops, a route planner or the routing inside your field service software earns its cost. Price it against your own drive time, not a vendor’s savings claim.

Most articles on this question are written by route planner vendors, and they all conclude that you need a route planner. This guide tries to be fairer. It shows exactly what Google Maps does and does not do, what the paid alternatives charge, where the savings claims come from, and a simple way to decide for your own crew. If you already run a field service platform, check what routing it includes before you buy anything extra, because the answer changes the decision. Our Jobber vs Housecall Pro comparison covers how those two handle scheduling.

Route planner vs Google Maps for field service teams graphic

Prices and limits below come from vendor and Google pages we read in November 2026. Where only a competitor or a review site reports a figure, we say so.

What Google Maps actually does for a multi-stop day

Google Maps gives you turn-by-turn directions with live traffic, and it lets you add stops. That is the whole job. The details matter.

QuestionWhat the sources say
How many stops?Google’s own help page for desktop says you can add up to 9 stops, which includes the final destination. Several third-party guides say 10 including the starting point. Treat the exact number as 9 to 10 and check your own app, since the mobile help tabs were not readable in our fetch.
Does it sort stops into the best order?The help page describes only dragging a destination to change the order. It does not mention optimizing or automatically reordering. Route planner vendors state the same limitation.
Can it split stops between technicians?No. A route belongs to one person.
Time windows, job length, skills?Not supported. You can add a stop, not a two-hour arrival window or a 90 minute job.
Can you add notes to a stop?A route planner vendor lists this as a gap. Check your version.
Does it change when a job cancels?You edit the list yourself.

None of this makes Google Maps a bad tool. It is excellent at what it is for, which is getting one driver from A to B in current traffic. The trouble starts when a dispatcher asks it to do something it was not built to do: decide the order.

The part nobody says out loud: order is the hard problem

With 5 stops there are 120 possible orders. With 8 there are 40,320. With 10 there are 3,628,800. A person can find a decent order for 5 stops by looking at a map. At 8 or more, with a customer who can only be seen after noon and a part pickup on the way, a decent guess is usually all you get.

A route planner solves the sequencing problem for you. It takes your list, your start and end points, and any constraints, and it returns an order. That is what “optimization” means in this category, and it is the thing Google Maps leaves to the dispatcher.

Stops on a tech’s dayTypical approachIs Google Maps enough?
3 to 5, fixed timesBook by area, drive in appointment orderUsually yes
6 to 8, flexible timesDispatcher groups by zone, drags to orderOften, with effort
9 or more, or two or more techsNeeds sequencing and splittingRarely
Time windows plus emergency addsNeeds re-optimizing during the dayNo

What a route planner adds

The features that matter for field service, in plain language:

  • Automatic sequencing. The tool picks the order.
  • Many stops. Import a list instead of typing addresses one at a time.
  • Multiple technicians. It splits jobs among crew members.
  • Time windows and job duration. A 9 to 11 customer is visited between 9 and 11, and a 2 hour job blocks 2 hours.
  • Re-optimizing. A cancellation or an emergency call reshuffles the rest of the day.
  • Customer updates. Arrival text messages, which depend on the product.
  • Proof of work. Photos and signatures, in tools that include them.

Note that two of these, time windows and job duration, are exactly what scheduling tools already store. That is why the next section matters.

You may already own a route optimizer

If you use a field service platform, routing may be part of it. The vendors describe it differently, and the details are not always public.

PlatformWhat the vendor saysLimits to know
JobberIts route optimization page says it builds routes for one person, a few team members or a whole crew, plans a day, several days or a week, and re-optimizes when a delay, cancellation or new job occurs. It considers each crew member’s start and end points and schedule.The page does not state which plans include it or the price, and does not mention time windows, skills, vehicle capacity or traffic. Ask Jobber before you rely on it.
Housecall ProIts help center says the Optimize by drive time button is available only on the MAX plan. Its feature page says routing works for one truck or a fleet, with live map and customer arrival updates.Plan restriction. You can lock jobs and re-run the optimization, per the help article.
WorkizOffers scheduling, a map view and GPS tracking features, depending on plan.Confirm routing depth directly. See our Housecall Pro vs Workiz comparison.
ServiceTitan, FieldEdge and similarOffer dispatch boards with varying routing. Third parties describe ServiceTitan’s Dispatch Pro as an add-on.Quote-based pricing. Verify what your quote includes.

A third-party HVAC dispatch review says routing in Jobber is available on its Connect plan and above and limited to anytime visits, and lists Housecall Pro Max at $299 a month on annual billing. We could not confirm those figures on the vendors’ pages, so treat them as unverified and check current pricing. The useful lesson is that routing is often tied to a higher plan tier. Compare the price difference between your current plan and the next tier with the price of a standalone planner.

If you are weighing Jobber against Workiz, add routing depth to your checklist.

What standalone route planners cost

Prices vary by billing unit, which makes headline numbers hard to compare.

ToolBillingPublished or reported priceSource note
Google MapsFree for the appFreeThe app is free. The developer APIs are billed separately.
Spoke Route Planner (formerly Circuit)Per driver subscriptionFree up to 10 stops per route, then $9.99 a month Lite or $19.99 Standard with unlimited stopsReported by a third-party review site. Spoke rebranded in October 2025, per another third party.
OptimoRoutePer driver per monthLite $35.10 and Pro $44.10, billed annuallyReported by aggregator and competitor pages. A competitor lists $39 and $49 monthly. Check the vendor’s page.
Route4MeQuote or per userCustom quoteA review notes that its FAQ quotes a different Pro price than its plan grid. Get the figure in writing.
MapQuestFree tierUp to 26 stops per route, per Jobber’s roundupVerify current limits.

Two cautions. First, several of these figures come from competitors writing comparison pages, and they have a motive to make rivals look expensive. Second, a per-driver plan for a six truck shop at roughly $35 to $45 per driver is about $210 to $270 a month, which is in the range of a plan tier upgrade in some field service platforms. That is why the next section does the math.

Does it pay? A worked example with your numbers

Vendors claim savings of 20 to 30 percent. One route planner says its optimization reduces drive time by an average of 20 to 30 percent compared with manual planning, and another says its optimization cuts fuel cost by 20 to 30 percent. Neither page shows its method, and both vendors sell the product. Treat them as an upper bound, not a forecast.

Use this instead:

Monthly value = technicians x working days x minutes saved per day / 60 x revenue or loaded cost per hour.

Here is a hypothetical, not a benchmark:

InputExample
Technicians4
Working days a month21
Drive minutes saved per tech per day20
Loaded cost per tech hour$55
Hours saved a month4 x 21 x 20 / 60 = 28
Value of saved hoursabout $1,540
Planner at $40 per driver$160 a month

If the 20 minutes becomes 5 minutes, the value drops to about $385, still above the cost. If your techs already work tight geographic zones, the saving could be near zero. The number that decides it is how many minutes your dispatcher currently loses to bad ordering, and you can find it by timing a real week.

A one week check

  1. For five days, record each tech’s stops, in order, and the actual drive time between them.
  2. Paste the same stops into Google Maps and into a free trial of a planner. Most planners offer a trial or a limited free plan.
  3. Compare total drive minutes, not the pretty map.
  4. Note how many times the schedule changed during the day and how long the change took.
  5. Multiply the difference by your cost per hour.

Where Google Maps still wins

  • Navigation quality. Traffic data and rerouting in a consumer app is hard to beat. Many route planners hand the final navigation to Google Maps or Apple Maps anyway.
  • Zero cost, zero training. Every tech already knows it.
  • Single stop days. If a tech goes from a shop to one job and back, you do not need anything else.
  • Rural, long-haul calls. When each job is 40 minutes from the last, ordering matters less than the number of trips.

Where it breaks for service work

  • No job duration. A route that looks short on the map can be a nine hour day once the jobs are added.
  • No constraints. Skills, licenses, parts on the truck and customer windows live somewhere else.
  • No shared view. A dispatcher cannot watch five Google Maps routes at once.
  • Manual re-planning. One cancellation can mean a text conversation to reshuffle.
  • Address handling. Pasting 10 or 20 addresses by hand invites typos and wrong pins.

If you build your own with Google’s APIs

Some shops hire a developer to build a routing tool. Google’s Routes API documentation lists a maximum of 25 intermediate waypoints per request and, for route matrix requests, 625 elements per request. It bills requests under different SKUs depending on features: Essentials covers basic requests with up to 10 intermediate waypoints, and Pro covers requests with traffic-aware options. For fleet-style optimization, Google sells a separate Route Optimization API billed per shipment, with one SKU for a single vehicle and another for two or more. The pricing tables are on Google’s pricing list and change, so read them before you commit to a build. For most contractors, buying a subscription is cheaper than building.

Decision table

Your situationSensible choice
1 to 2 techs, under 6 stops a dayGoogle Maps plus a good schedule
3 to 6 techs, mostly booked by zoneRouting inside your field service software if the plan includes it
3 or more techs with time windows and daily changesSoftware routing or a per-driver planner
10 or more techs, many appointments, specialized skillsDispatch tooling in a full platform, such as the ones in our ServiceTitan vs FieldEdge comparison
Recurring route-based service (lawn, pest, pool)A platform built around recurring routes
HOW WE SOURCED THIS
Google Maps limits come from Google’s help page and its Routes API documentation. Plan restrictions come from Housecall Pro’s help center and Jobber’s route optimization page. Third-party prices and savings claims are labeled as such, and vendor claims are treated as unverified.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing a planner’s price with a savings claim from its own marketing.
  • Buying a separate planner before checking what your current plan includes.
  • Optimizing distance when your real constraint is arrival windows.
  • Ignoring job length when planning stops per day.
  • Skipping a one week comparison with your real jobs.
  • Letting techs reorder the route without telling the dispatcher.

Route planner vs Google Maps FAQ

Can Google Maps optimize a route?

Google’s help page describes dragging stops to reorder them and does not mention automatic optimization. You choose the order.

How many stops can you add in Google Maps?

Google’s desktop help page says up to 9 stops including the final destination. Other sources say 10 including the start, so check your own app.

Is a route planner worth it for a small field service business?

It depends on drive time saved. Run a one week comparison and use the monthly value formula above before paying.

Does Jobber have route optimization?

Yes, Jobber’s page describes automatic route building and re-optimizing for delays and cancellations. It does not list the plans or price, so confirm with Jobber.

Does Housecall Pro optimize routes?

Its help center says Optimize by drive time is available only on the MAX plan, with locked jobs respected on re-runs.

How much does a standalone route planner cost?

Reported prices include $9.99 to $19.99 a month for a solo driver app and roughly $35 to $49 per driver a month for team tools. Verify with each vendor.

What is the difference between a route planner and dispatch software?

A planner sequences stops. Dispatch software also assigns jobs, tracks status and links to invoicing. Many field service platforms include both.

Can I use the Google Maps API to build my own planner?

Yes, but the Routes API limits requests to 25 intermediate waypoints and bills by SKU. Fleet optimization is a separate paid API.

Sources

Author

  • Michael Carter

    I’m Michael Carter, a field service, ERP, and digital transformation expert with more than 13 years of experience helping service-based businesses improve their operations through better processes and technology.
    My experience covers the full spectrum of field service management, including technician scheduling, dispatching, work orders, preventive maintenance, asset management, inventory, service contracts, customer management, mobile workforce management, reporting, and operational automation. I also have extensive knowledge of ERP, CRM, and field service management platforms and how they can work together to create connected service operations.
    At Field Services HQ, I cover a wide range of topics related to field service and service business technology. This includes FSM software comparisons, ERP implementation, ERPNext, CRM integration, scheduling and dispatch solutions, maintenance management, technician productivity, AI in field service, automation, mobile applications, analytics, and emerging industry trends.
    I take a practical approach to technology. I look beyond features and focus on how a solution can actually solve operational problems, improve workflows, and deliver measurable value for a service business.
    Through my content, I aim to help business owners, field service managers, operations teams, and technicians understand the technologies and strategies that can make modern field service operations more efficient, connected, and scalable.

Scroll to Top